Earned Secure Attachment: How Security Gets Built, Even If You Didn't Start With It

You've read about attachment styles and recognized yourself, maybe in the anxious description, maybe the avoidant one, maybe some mix. It explained a lot. Then a harder question came up: is this just who I am? If your early relationships taught you that love was unpredictable, or that needing people wasn't safe, are you stuck relating this way for the rest of your life?

In my experience, no. A secure attachment style is something some people are lucky enough to grow up with, but it can also be built later, in relationship. When that happens it's often called earned secure attachment. In this post I want to talk about what security actually means (it's often misunderstood), whether attachment styles can change, and what earning security tends to look like, including in the therapy relationship itself.

What is a secure attachment style?

A lot of people assume that being secure means not really needing anyone. In this picture, the secure person is fine on their own, rarely anxious about where they stand with someone, and not especially dependent on anybody. I hear this often, and I think it gets secure attachment almost backwards. What people are describing sounds a lot more like avoidant attachment.

The way I understand it, secure attachment has two parts. The first, and I think the most important, is being able to trust that someone else's love, affection and care are reliable rather than fragile. That trust rests on something deeper, which is the belief that you are worthy of love and can be loved. It's what allows someone to rely on another person's consistent care without bracing for it to disappear.

The second part is flexibility in how you relate to the parts of yourself that sometimes feel anxious or want to pull away. Secure people have those parts too, but they aren't run by them as much.

What security looks like in real relationships (and what it doesn't)

People with a secure attachment style still feel anxious at times, and they still feel the urge to pull back. The difference is that those reactions tend to fit the situation. If a partner is becoming unreliable, a secure person might feel worried about where they stand, which makes sense given what's happening. If someone is becoming overbearing, they might feel an impulse to set limits and boundaries. There's room to move in either direction, and they're less likely to end up stuck at one extreme of the anxious-avoidant range.

Dependence also isn't treated as a weakness or a flaw. Someone with an avoidant pattern may believe, consciously or not, that needing people is a kind of failure (I wrote more about where that comes from in Therapy for Avoidant Attachment). People with a more secure attachment tend to seek out relationships and healthy dependence, what I often call interdependence. They can be vulnerable and lean on others. Endings and breakups still hurt, sometimes a great deal, but they can let themselves feel the loss without being drowned by it indefinitely.

Can attachment styles change?

When clients ask me this, I tell them that yes, I think so and that I’ve seen it. I also tell them it takes time, which makes sense when you consider how attachment patterns form. They're created and reinforced over years, usually starting in childhood and then confirmed again in later relationships. It would be surprising if they shifted overnight.

What helps them change, in my experience, is getting to know the parts of you that drive the pattern. That might be the part that floods with anxiety when a text goes unanswered and starts replaying the last conversation (something I describe in How to Heal Anxious Attachment), or the part that wants to get out as soon as someone gets close. When those parts can be seen and related to, instead of fought or ignored, they have the opportunity to receive what they never had. And what they never had is usually what led to the insecure attachment in the first place.

What is earned secure attachment?

Earned secure attachment is a term from attachment research for people who didn't grow up with consistent, attuned care but who come to relate to others in a secure way later in life. It usually happens through relationship: a partner, a close friend, a mentor, or a therapist, someone whose steadiness slowly contradicts what you learned to expect.

I like the word "earned," though I'd add that it doesn't mean you have to work harder than everyone else to deserve being loved (people with insecure attachment often already believe that). It's closer to the idea that security can be learned through experience, over and over, until your body starts to believe it.

How earned security gets built in therapy

The therapy relationship can be a significant part of this. For some people who come to therapy, it's possible they've never felt fully trusting or cared for in any relationship. So the experience of having someone attuned to you, present with you, and focused on your needs can itself be a first step.

As the relationship deepens (and for some people, right from the beginning), the old patterns tend to show up with me too. You might notice my facial expression change in reaction to something you said and worry that I'm judging you. You might start ruminating between sessions about what I think of you, or whether I actually care. Or you might feel the urge to pull away just as we start to explore something more painful, or after a session where you felt closer to me, maybe one where you cried, or where I shared that I felt a heavy heart hearing about something painful you'd been through.

Those moments are a big part of the work. Being able to talk about them openly with me takes a great deal of trust, and doing it is a step toward greater vulnerability, authenticity and honesty in relationships. It means we get to work with your attachment patterns as they're happening, in a live setting, instead of only talking about them after the fact.

Then there are ruptures and repairs. Say you were unhappy with the way I phrased something. In the past, you might have kept it to yourself so as not to "make it a big deal." But because we've talked about this being part of the work, you decide to tell me. I take you seriously. We try to understand together what happened and what led to those feelings. Sometimes it includes me acknowledging my part. What you get from that is the experience of conflict or disagreement without being punished or retaliated against.

Over time, that experience gets internalized. You start to take in that it's possible to express yourself openly and still be cared for, and that your internal experience is worth taking seriously. You learn, slowly, that you don't have to hide parts of yourself in order to be loved. I think that's at the heart of earned security.

What changes over time

What I tend to see is different depending on where someone started. For people with a more anxious pattern, there's often a growing capacity to sit with uncertainty and with the fear of rejection, without needing it resolved right away. For people with a more avoidant pattern, there's often a growing capacity for love, tenderness, warmth and connection. For people with a more disorganized attachment style, there's often a better ability to regulate themselves and to connect in a more consistent way.

With avoidant clients in particular, something else often happens. As the walls begin to come down, what's underneath is anxiety, the same anxiety the avoidance was protecting them from. So there's another layer of work, getting to know that newer anxiety and what it's about.

I think of clients with an anxious pattern who are uncomfortable with any silence in a session. Some of them get angry with me about it, much the way they might with a partner who goes quiet. In those moments I might say something like: "I understand, and I'm sorry this feels frustrating and anxiety-provoking. I want you to know I'm here and I'm listening. If I don't fill the silence, it's because I don't always have something I feel I need to say, and I wouldn't want to force it and be disingenuous. But I can see it's hard for you, so maybe we can try to understand what the silence brings up." After moments like that, I've seen clients begin to accept that other people relate and process in their own ways. They don't need everyone to meet their needs in one specific way, which leaves a lot more room in their relationships.

With clients who are more avoidant, emotional expression can be rare, and the sessions can stay at a certain distance. At some point I might share what I'm noticing in myself. Sometimes that's: "As you talk about this memory, which sounds really painful, I notice I'm not feeling much. I'd expect a heavy heart, but it feels kind of flat. Is that similar for you?" Other times it's the opposite: "As you're speaking, I notice I feel a heavy heart, almost like my eyes want to water. It seems like that isn't really what you're experiencing. What do you make of that?" I've also described it as feeling like there's a glass wall between us. Moments like these, of deeper connection, vulnerability and trust, are what allow other relationships to become healthier and more secure too.

How to become securely attached outside of therapy

Therapy isn't the only place security grows. It can also build in relationships with partners and friends, and as clients become more secure, I tend to notice changes in how they show up there too. These shifts are signs that security is growing, and they're also part of how it grows.

One of the first is clearer boundaries. Many clients used to let things happen that didn't feel right, and then later feel the urge to pull away or get angry. As they become more secure, they're more able to say what does and doesn't work for them in the moment, before it builds into resentment or distance.

They also become more able to tell a friend or partner how they actually feel, including when something hurt, instead of keeping it to themselves. And many start to feel more drawn to friends and partners who are reliable and secure. That can be a real change, because people with an insecure pattern often aren't very drawn to secure people at first. Someone steady can seem boring, especially next to someone who keeps them guessing. As security grows, that steadiness becomes more appealing.

And over time, many begin, willingly, to put themselves in situations that feel uncomfortable, so they can get closer to what they're afraid of. For someone with a more anxious pattern, that might mean joining a class, meeting new people, and sitting with the uncertainty of not knowing how they're coming across or whether anything will come of it. For someone with a more avoidant pattern, it might mean joining that same class and then following up with someone to actually make plans.

Working with me

If you recognize yourself in any of this, you don't have to figure it out alone. In my work, I help people understand where their attachment patterns came from, how they show up in their relationships today, and what it might feel like to relate differently, with others and with me. You can read more about how I work with relationships and attachment and individual therapy.

I see clients in person in Manhattan and online throughout New York and Florida. If you'd like to talk about whether working together might be a good fit, you can schedule a free consultation.

Sources

Doriel Jacov, JD, LCSW

Doriel Jacov, JD, LCSW, is a psychodynamic, somatic, and trauma-informed psychotherapist in Midtown Manhattan, seeing clients in person in NYC and online across New York and Florida. Before becoming a therapist, he practiced law at a big law firm. He has been quoted in Forbes, HuffPost, USA Today, and Vice.

https://linkedin.com/in/doriel-jacov-jd-lcsw-76190632
Next
Next

Anxious Avoidant Attachment: The Trap of Pulling Each Other In and Pushing Each Other Away